Doctrine

☪

Hadith

Also known as: Ahadith, Prophetic Tradition, Prophetic Reports

The recorded sayings, actions, and approvals of Prophet Muhammad, transmitted through chains of narrators and compiled in written collections. Hadith literature is the second most authoritative source in Islam after the Quran, providing practical details for implementing Islamic teachings and understanding Muhammad’s example (Sunnah).

Definition and Components

What is a Hadith?

Arabic: حديث (hadith)

Literally: “statement,” “report,” “account,” “narrative”
Plural: ahadith (أحاديث)
Technically: Reports of Muhammad’s words, deeds, tacit approvals, physical descriptions

Structure of a Hadith

Every hadith consists of two parts:

1. Isnad (السند) - Chain of Transmission:

List of narrators from final compiler back to Muhammad
Example: “Bukhari said: ‘Abu Nu’aym told us from Zakariya from Amir from Abu Mas’ud that the Prophet said…’”
Allows verification of authenticity

2. Matn (المتن) - Text/Content:

The actual report of what Muhammad said or did
The substance of the hadith
What scholars analyze for meaning

Example Structure:

[Isnad] “Ibn Umar reported that the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) said:” [Matn] “‘Islam is built upon five: testifying that there is no god but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah’s messenger, establishing prayer, giving zakat, fasting Ramadan, and pilgrimage to the House.’”

Difference from Quran

Quran

Literal words of Allah
Revealed verbatim through Angel Jibril
Recited in Arabic in prayer
Eternally uncreated (Sunni view)
Inimitable, miraculous language
Memorized and written from Muhammad’s time
Universally agreed upon text

Hadith

Muhammad’s words (or actions described)
Not divine revelation directly (though inspired)
Not recited in prayer
Created/human transmission
Ordinary language
Compiled 150-250 years after Muhammad
Varying degrees of authenticity

Yet both essential: Quran provides principles; Hadith provides application

Types of Hadith

By Source

1. Hadith Qudsi (Sacred Hadith):

Allah’s words on Muhammad’s tongue
Wording from Muhammad, meaning from Allah
Example: “O My servants, I have forbidden oppression for Myself and have made it forbidden amongst you, so do not oppress one another”
~100 such hadith

2. Hadith Nabawi (Prophetic Hadith):

Muhammad’s own words, inspired by his prophetic understanding
Vast majority of hadith
Basis for Sunnah

By Content

1. Qawli (Verbal):

Muhammad’s sayings and teachings
“Actions are judged by intentions”
Most common type

2. Fi’li (Actual):

Muhammad’s actions described
How he prayed, performed ablution, conducted Hajj
Practical application

3. Taqriri (Tacit Approval):

Things Muhammad witnessed and didn’t forbid
Companions’ actions he approved
Indicates permissibility

4. Wasfi (Descriptive):

Physical descriptions of Muhammad
Character traits
Appearance

Classification by Authenticity

Science of Hadith Criticism (‘Ilm al-Hadith)

Scholars developed rigorous methodology to determine authenticity:

Criteria:

Chain continuity: Complete, unbroken narrator chain
Narrator reliability: Memory, honesty, piety of each person
No hidden defects: No contradictions or anachronisms
No irregularity: Doesn’t contradict more reliable reports
Not contradicting Quran: Must align with Quranic teachings

Authenticity Categories

1. Sahih (صحيح) - Authentic:

Highest grade
Continuous chain of trustworthy narrators
No defects
Example: Most of Sahih Bukhari

2. Hasan (حسن) - Good:

Chain complete
Narrators trustworthy but slightly less strict than Sahih
Acceptable for legal rulings

3. Da’if (ضعيف) - Weak:

Break in chain
Unreliable narrator
Contradiction
Not used for legal rulings
May be used for virtuous deeds (debated)

4. Mawdu’ (موضوع) - Fabricated:

Forged, invented
Completely rejected
Unfortunately, many fabricated hadith exist

Additional Classifications

Mutawatir (متواتر - Mass-transmitted):

Narrated by so many people at each level that fabrication is impossible
Highest certainty
Relatively rare

Ahad (آحاد - Singular chain):

Transmitted by limited narrators
Most hadith
Further subdivided: famous, rare, unique

Major Hadith Collections

Sunni Collections

The Six Books (Kutub as-Sittah):

1. Sahih al-Bukhari (Muhammad al-Bukhari, d. 870 CE):

Most authentic (Sunni view)
Compiled from 600,000 narrations, accepted ~7,275
Rigorous standards
Organized by topic
Second only to Quran in authority

2. Sahih Muslim (Muslim ibn al-Hajjaj, d. 875 CE):

Ranked second in authenticity
Different organization
~7,500 hadith
Complements Bukhari

Al-Bukhari and Muslim together: Hadith accepted by both considered strongest (muttafaq alayh)

3. Sunan Abu Dawood (d. 889 CE):

Focus on legal hadith
~5,000 hadith
Practical rulings

4. Jami’ at-Tirmidhi (d. 892 CE):

Includes grading of each hadith
Legal and ethical hadith
~4,000 hadith

5. Sunan an-Nasa’i (d. 915 CE):

Strict authentication
~5,000 hadith
Legal focus

6. Sunan Ibn Majah (d. 887 CE):

~4,000 hadith
Some weaker narrations

Other important collections:

Muwatta Imam Malik: Earliest collection (8th century)
Musnad Ahmad ibn Hanbal: Massive collection organized by narrator
Riyadh as-Salihin: Topically arranged for easy reference

Shia Collections

Four Books (Al-Kutub al-Arba’ah):

Al-Kafi (Kulayni, d. 941 CE): Most important Shia collection
Man La Yahduruhu al-Faqih (Ibn Babawayh, d. 991 CE)
Tahdhib al-Ahkam (Tusi, d. 1067 CE)
Al-Istibsar (Tusi)

Differences from Sunni:

Rely heavily on reports from Imams (Ali’s descendants)
Different chains of transmission
Imams’ interpretations given high authority

Examples of Famous Hadith

On Intention

“Actions are judged by intentions, so each man will have what he intended.” (Bukhari, Muslim)

On Faith

“None of you truly believes until he loves for his brother what he loves for himself.” (Bukhari, Muslim)

On Knowledge

“Seeking knowledge is an obligation upon every Muslim.” (Ibn Majah)

On Kindness

“He who is not merciful to others, will not be treated mercifully.” (Bukhari, Muslim)

On Rights

“A Muslim is the brother of a Muslim. He neither oppresses him nor humiliates him nor looks down upon him.” (Muslim)

On Moderation

“Religion is very easy and whoever overburdens himself will not be able to continue in that way.” (Bukhari)

On Parenting

“He is not of us who does not have mercy on young children, nor honor the elderly.” (Tirmidhi)

How Hadith Were Preserved

Oral Transmission

During Muhammad’s lifetime:

Companions memorized his teachings
Repeated and taught others
Arab oral culture highly developed
Memorization skills exceptional

After Muhammad’s death:

Companions continued narrating
Students (tabi’un) learned from companions
Chain of transmission established

Written Collection

Early Period (7th-8th century):

Private notes by some companions
Not systematically organized
Quran prioritized for writing

Compilation Era (8th-9th century)**:

Scholars traveled extensively seeking hadith
Interviewed narrators
Verified chains
Compiled collections
Developed authentication science

Example: Bukhari’s Method:

Traveled for 16 years
Interviewed 1,000+ teachers
Examined 600,000 narrations
Accepted only ~7,000
Prayed two rak’ahs before accepting each hadith

Role in Islamic Law (Sharia)

Sources of Islamic Law

Primary:

Quran: First source
Hadith/Sunnah: Second source

Secondary: 3. Ijma: Scholarly consensus 4. Qiyas: Analogical reasoning

Applications

Ritual Law:

How to pray (movements, recitations, times)
Ablution procedures
Hajj rituals
Fasting details

Family Law:

Marriage contracts
Divorce procedures
Child custody
Inheritance (supplementing Quran)

Criminal Law:

Hudud punishments
Evidence requirements
Judicial procedures

Business Ethics:

Prohibited transactions (riba/interest)
Contract requirements
Fair trade practices

Social Interactions:

Greetings
Visiting sick
Funeral rites
Hospitality

Contemporary Issues

Authentication Debates

Traditionalist View:

Classical authentication methods reliable
Major collections (especially Bukhari, Muslim) trustworthy
Chains verified by early scholars

Modernist/Revisionist View:

Compiled 200+ years after Muhammad—room for error
Some narrators may be unreliable
Need to re-examine with modern critical methods
Distinguish authentic from weak more rigorously

Quranist View (minority):

Reject all hadith
Quran alone sufficient
Hadith corrupted/unreliable
Mainstream Islam rejects this view

Problematic Hadith

Some hadith seem to conflict with:

Modern values (women’s rights, slavery, punishment severity)
Scientific knowledge
Quranic principles

Responses:

Check authenticity (many problematic hadith are weak/fabricated)
Understand historical context
Distinguish universal principles from culture-specific applications
Recognize metaphor vs. literal meaning

Fabricated Hadith

Why fabricated?:

Political agendas (supporting various factions)
Promoting piety (inventing rewards for good deeds)
Opposing enemies
Gaining fame or money

Examples of fabrications:

Extreme sectarian claims
Superstitions (often attributed to Muhammad)
Contradicting Quran clearly

Scholarly response:

Books written on fabricated hadith
Warning Muslims to verify
Relying on authenticated collections

Significance

For Muslims, Hadith:

Explains Quran: Details what Quran outlines
Preserves Sunnah: Records Muhammad’s example
Guides practice: Shows how to live Islamically
Inspires character: Models Muhammad’s ethics
Unifies community: Shared reference across cultures
Shapes law: Second source for Islamic jurisprudence

Why Hadith Matters

Without Hadith:

Wouldn’t know how to pray
Couldn’t perform Hajj correctly
Unclear on many legal matters
Missing Muhammad’s spiritual wisdom
Lost practical application of Quran

With Hadith:

Complete religious system
Comprehensive guidance
Muhammad’s example accessible
Quran’s teachings implemented

Memorization Culture

Huffaz (memorizers):

Not just Quran, but hadith too
Scholars memorized thousands
Oral transmission ensured preservation
Written collections verified oral memory

Comparative Perspective

Similarities to other traditions:

Christian Gospels (record Jesus’s words/deeds)
Jewish Mishnah/Talmud (oral law written down)
Buddhist sutras (Buddha’s teachings)

Differences:

More systematic authentication methodology
Explicit chain of transmission
Later compilation (150-250 years vs. immediate)

The Living Tradition

Hadith study continues:

Traditional scholars: Memorizing chains, studying classical texts
Modern scholars: Applying hadith to contemporary issues
Digital age: Hadith databases, apps, searchable collections
Academic study: Western scholars examining hadith critically

Significance

Hadith literature represents Islam’s effort to preserve and transmit prophetic wisdom across generations and geographies. Through meticulous chain verification, scholars created one of history’s most sophisticated authentication systems.

For Muslims, opening Sahih Bukhari isn’t just reading ancient text—it’s encountering Muhammad’s voice, accessing his guidance, learning his character. When a Muslim quotes, “The best of you are those who are best to their families,” they’re not citing abstract principle but prophetic precedent, tested through centuries of transmission, authenticated by rigorous scholarship, and lived by millions worldwide.

The hadith tradition testifies to Islam’s commitment to preserving not just divine revelation (Quran) but prophetic application (Sunnah). It acknowledges that truth requires both: God’s word and God’s messenger’s example. Together, Quran and Hadith provide the complete guidance Muslims seek—one revealing what Allah wants, the other showing how His final prophet lived it.

Whether studying how Muhammad prayed, how he treated neighbors, how he conducted business, or how he faced hardship, Muslims turn to hadith. There they find not just rules but a role model, not just law but life, not just commands but character—making Islam not merely a set of beliefs but a comprehensive way of living, modeled first by Muhammad and followed, imperfectly but devotedly, by his community across fourteen centuries.